Cheesecake.
It is a classic. Forever trendy.
First, congratulations! Muddy Paws Cheesecake is the best dessert you could possibly serve guests at your wedding. Muddy Paws Cheesecake has catered over 22,000 weddings with cheesecake! Our wedding couples have all told us how excited their guests were to be served cheesecake! They come visit us too, which we love! Our first wedding couple has kids finishing college now….wow!
Muddy Paws Cheesecake offers several ways to serve cheesecake during your big day. Call to set up an appointment with Meg or Tami and they'll ensure all of your expectations are met. If you want to bypass the meeting* and go straight to ordering that's fine too! *If you want to skip the mtg, stop by for 3 free slices on us, anytime [same amt of slices you'd get in the meeting].
Here are a few ways Muddy Paws Cheesecake serves cheesecake at weddings:
Tiered Cheesecake
With 8 different sizes ranging from 6" - 12", the options are endless for display options including fresh fruit, your wedding flowers, cheesecake toppers. A 3 Tier Cheesecake is the most popular. It serves 44-48 and is $157 [any 3 traditional flavors] See our flavor page for flavors!
This is a 2 tier stacked cheesecake (serves 20). 3 Tier Stacked or Floating are also very popular!
Cheesecake Centerpieces
Cheesecakes make beautiful centerpieces! Giving your guests flexibility with a variety of flavors is the perfect option for dessert and allows guests to serve themselves after dinner. You may choose 7”, 9” or mini cheesecakes for centerpieces. See our flavors page for flavors and prices.
Mini Cheesecakes
With two different size mini cheesecakes, this is a great way for your guests to indulge in a variety of flavors. Combining full cheesecakes with mini cheesecakes is also an option! We offer petite minis and cupcake cheesecakes. They are both 2.75” in size and are $3 each. You may order 1 flavor per 24. Order 1 pp plus 20-30% extra. These come in the following flavors: Chocolate, New York, Key Lime, Lemon, Raspberry, Turtle, Pumpkin, Banana Cream, Strawberry, Choc PB Chip, Choc Chip, Espresso, Butterscotch, Mocha, Oreo or Almond.
SHEET CHEESECAKES
We only recommend these if you can keep them cold till serving time. They get soft quickly. They can be self serve but a helper is advisable. Sheet Cheesecakes can be cut into 48, 60 or 72 squares. They are $65 uncut or $71 cut. Choose any traditional flavors!
EXTRAS
BRIDE/GROOM Strawberries: $12 for 2. Keep refrigerated up to 24 hours.
Regular Chocolate Strawberries: $1.50 each. Min order: 1 dozen. Keep refrigerated up to 24 hours.
Sauces and Toppings Bar: $5 each [8oz container. Enough for one cake.] Options: Strawberry sauce, Raspberry sauce, Caramel Topping, Chocolate Topping, Graham cracker crust crumbles, Oreo crumbles, Can of whip cream, Cherry Topping or Blueberry Topping.
Cake Stands: Pedestals rent for $3 each. Plateaus rent for $5-$25. Tiered Stands rent for $25-$35. See our cake stand page for pics. They must be returned within 10 days and we need a credit card on file for them.
Serving Spatulas, Trays or Tongs: we rent Spatulas for $2 each. For disposable trays, serving Spatulas, plates, forks, napkins and tongs [minis], we highly recommend Litin’s Party Value!
Fresh Fruit: we can provide the following fresh fruit: $7 pkg: blueberries, strawberries, raspberries. You may also pickup fruit up at any grocery store. Place fruit on the cakes at time of setup.
Brownies: we’re almost as famous for our brownies! They are $1.50 each. They come in quantities of 18. [18, 36, etc]
Chocolate Chip or PB Cookies: $1.50 each. These come in quantities of 24 [24, 48, etc].
FAQ
You may pick the cheesecakes up as early as 4 weeks [or any day before the wedding] and store them in a freezer until the wedding day. We'll give you instructions on when and how to setup. It's very easy to set them up! [Side note: chest freezers are a great gift.. wink wink. They sell them at Menards for under $100.]
For day of pickup, bring them directly to the site freezer/refrigerator or put them in camping coolers. They'll stay cold in coolers up to 12 hours. They also travel very well in coolers for long drives.
It's easy to set up the cheesecakes yourselves [or a helper] but many sites also offer to set them out.
Cake toppers: the cheesecakes can hold just about any cake topper. The cheesecakes are approximately 2.5” high.
We also offer delivery Wednesday thru Friday 11a-4p if your site can receive them early and keep them frozen. We make them fresh to order but freezing them does not affect quality or taste in any way.
Occasionally we can deliver and setup at your site but since the pandemic, we are short staffed and especially on drivers. Thank you for your understanding on this. We're just so thankful to still be here, making beautiful cheesecakes and weddings special! They travel fantastic in a Coleman (or any cooler) Cooler and stay cold in them for 10-12 hours.
We will supply flavor tents so guests know what flavor each cheesecake is.
Let us know any questions or how we can help by emailing us! Place orders at least 10 days in advance. The prices on our website are the same for weddings.
We were featured on the Food Network for our Cupcake Cheesecakes! ($2.75 each)
Camp Cheesecake
Our cheesecake food truck (the world's first!) that is out of a vintage camper! Hire us for your next event or for your wedding! Visit campcheesecake.com or email us at yummy@muddypawscheesecake.com for info. It does book up quickly though. It's about $275 extra and we only travel within a 10 mile radius of bakery per how vintage it is. It's very cute!
When you are ready to place your order, email Tami at yummy@muddypawscheesecake.com! We need at least 10 days notice.
CONGRATULATIONS! WE'D BE HONORED TO BE PART OF YOUR STORY!
